Notes
Slide Show
Outline
1
Information Seeking
  • Module 1 Min-Yen KAN


  • Fundamentals of LIS
2
Why “seeking”?
  • Don’t want to limit to “retrieval”
  • IR: match query to documents.
  • Seeking as the larger context: berrypicking






    • We’ll revisit IR later in another lecture
3
Information Need
  • Taylor’s (68) model of need


    • Visceral: The actual, but unexpressed need


    • Conscious: ________________


    • Formalized: e.g., a search statement


    • Compromised:_________________
4
Berry Picking
  • “… picking blueberries in the forest.  The berries are scattered on the bushes; they do not come in bunches.  One must pick them one at a time…”
  • - paraphrased from Bates (89)


    • The nature of the query is an evolving one


    • The nature of the search process is such that it follows a berrypicking pattern


    • The query is satisfied not by a final set of documents but by __________________
5
Information Foraging
  • Techniques that expert searchers use:


    • _____
    • _____
    • _____
    • _____
    • _____
    • _____


  • To think about: How well does LINC support these functions?  How about Google?
6
Vocabulary Problem
  • The fact that a user is looking for something means that they don’t know what exactly they are looking for (otherwise, they wouldn’t be looking in the first place)
  • - paraphrased from Belkin et al. (82)


    • Therefore, they may not be using the right vocabulary to express their needs.


7
Anomalous State of Knowledge
  • means that the seeker realizes that there is a gap or lack of knowledge in some area: an ASK.


    • Partial or even incorrect search results can alter the ASK and change the seeker’s perception.
8
Three aspects of Information Seeking
9
Cognitive Factors
  • Selecting a source that is most relevant and useful
    • Purpose
    • Authority
    • Scope
    • Audience
    • Cost
    • Format


10
Affective Factors – Kuhlthau (93)
  • Initiation: uncertainty
  • Selection: optimism
  • Exploration: confusion/frustration/doubt
  • Formulation: clarity
  • Collection: sense of direction and confidence
  • Presentation: satisfaction or disappointment


11
Implications of Kuhlthau (93)
  • Users tend to try to move towards
    ______________
  • Vague, invitation mode transforms to focused, indicative mode
  • Corollaries:
    • Too much redundant information = __
    • Too much unique information = __
    • Unfocused search without selection/formulation gives information overload = __
12
Situational Factors
  • Often the most important situational factor:
  • Perceived source accessibility


  • Principle of Least Effort – Zipf 49
    • Rural libraries get less utilized than urban ones
    • RBR / ILL services / acquisition library features rarely used


13
Dimensions of Accessibility –
Culnan (85)
  • Physical / Automated library
    • Physical: Location, location, location!
    • Interface: Catalog use, organization of library
    • Informational: locating the book, article


  • Digital library
    • Physical:
    • Interface:
    • Informational:


14
Quality is (often) secondary!
  • People often access easily accessible material first irrespective of quality


  • But informed professionals accept ideas from sources in proportion to their technical quality


  • But what about the uninformed?
15
Putting the models together