Skip to content
No results
  • Home
  • About
    • The School
      • Overview
      • Dean’s Message
      • Our History
      • Teaching Awards
      • Work with Us
      • Locate Us
      • Contact Us
    • Departments
      • Department of Computer Science
      • Department of Information Systems and Analytics
    • People
      • Leadership
      • Conversation With Leadership
      • Industry Advisory Committee
      • Staff Tribute
      • Faculty & Staff
    • News and Events
      • News
      • Events
      • Knowledge@Computing
  • Education
    • Undergraduate
      • Artificial Intelligence
      • Business Analytics
      • Business Artificial Intelligence Systems
      • Computer Engineering
      • Computer Science
      • Information Security
      • Special Programmes
      • Double Major
      • Minors
      • Current Undergraduate Students
      • Information for Freshmen
    • Graduate
      • PhD in Computer Science
      • PhD in Information Systems
      • Master of Computing (with Specialisations)
      • Master of Computing (General Track)
      • Master of Computing in Artificial Intelligence
      • Master of Science in Digital FinTech
      • Master of Science in Business Analytics
      • Executive Master in AI & Digital Transformation
      • Graduate Certificates
      • Graduate Certificate in Computing Foundations
    • Executive Education & Part-time Programmes
      • Advanced Computing for Executives
      • Bachelor of Technology
  • Community
    • Student Life
      • Overview
      • Student Awards
      • Financial Support
      • Student Wellness and Wellbeing
      • Student Clubs/Interest Groups
    • Social Good and Excellence
      • Centre for Computing for Social Good and Philanthropy (CCSGP)
      • Centre for Nurturing Computing Excellence (CENCE)
    • Our Heritage
      • NUS Computing Gallery
  • Research
    • Research
      • Overview
      • Research Centres
      • Research Areas
      • Research Partnership
    • Research Highlights
      • Knowledge@Computing
      • Special Issue Research Bulletin
  • Entrepreneurship
    • Innovation and Entrepreneurship
      • Overview
      • Leadership
      • Innovation
      • Funding Opportunities
      • Alumni Companies
      • News
    • Awards & Competitions
      • Venture Initiation Programme@NUSComputing
      • NUS Computing Innovation Prize
      • Asian Business Plan Competition
    • The Furnace
      • Overview
      • Start-ups
  • Industry
    • Industry Relations
      • Overview
      • IndustryConnect (iConnect)
      • Career Fair
      • Career Services
    • Internships
      • Overview
      • For Employers
      • For Students
    • Translational Research
      • Computing Translational Research and Development Centre (C-TReND)
  • Giving
  • Current Students
  • MySoC
  • News
  • Events
  • Alumni
NUS Computing
  • Current Students
  • MySoC
  • News
  • Events
  • Alumni
  • Home
  • About
    • The School
      • Overview
      • Dean’s Message
      • Our History
      • Teaching Awards
      • Work with Us
      • Locate Us
      • Contact Us
    • Departments
      • Department of Computer Science
      • Department of Information Systems and Analytics
    • People
      • Leadership
      • Conversation With Leadership
      • Industry Advisory Committee
      • Staff Tribute
      • Faculty & Staff
    • News and Events
      • News
      • Events
      • Knowledge@Computing
  • Education
    • Undergraduate
      • Artificial Intelligence
      • Business Analytics
      • Business Artificial Intelligence Systems
      • Computer Engineering
      • Computer Science
      • Information Security
      • Special Programmes
      • Double Major
      • Minors
      • Current Undergraduate Students
      • Information for Freshmen
    • Graduate
      • PhD in Computer Science
      • PhD in Information Systems
      • Master of Computing (with Specialisations)
      • Master of Computing (General Track)
      • Master of Computing in Artificial Intelligence
      • Master of Science in Digital FinTech
      • Master of Science in Business Analytics
      • Executive Master in AI & Digital Transformation
      • Graduate Certificates
      • Graduate Certificate in Computing Foundations
    • Executive Education & Part-time Programmes
      • Advanced Computing for Executives
      • Bachelor of Technology
  • Community
    • Student Life
      • Overview
      • Student Awards
      • Financial Support
      • Student Wellness and Wellbeing
      • Student Clubs/Interest Groups
    • Social Good and Excellence
      • Centre for Computing for Social Good and Philanthropy (CCSGP)
      • Centre for Nurturing Computing Excellence (CENCE)
    • Our Heritage
      • NUS Computing Gallery
  • Research
    • Research
      • Overview
      • Research Centres
      • Research Areas
      • Research Partnership
    • Research Highlights
      • Knowledge@Computing
      • Special Issue Research Bulletin
  • Entrepreneurship
    • Innovation and Entrepreneurship
      • Overview
      • Leadership
      • Innovation
      • Funding Opportunities
      • Alumni Companies
      • News
    • Awards & Competitions
      • Venture Initiation Programme@NUSComputing
      • NUS Computing Innovation Prize
      • Asian Business Plan Competition
    • The Furnace
      • Overview
      • Start-ups
  • Industry
    • Industry Relations
      • Overview
      • IndustryConnect (iConnect)
      • Career Fair
      • Career Services
    • Internships
      • Overview
      • For Employers
      • For Students
    • Translational Research
      • Computing Translational Research and Development Centre (C-TReND)
  • Giving
NUS Computing

Beyond Paywalls and Profits

1 October 2020
Computational Social Science, Department of Information Systems & Analytics, Faculty, Feature, Research
Home » Knowledge@Computing » Beyond Paywalls and Profits
CHEN Nan
Chen Nan
Assistant Professor
Information Systems and Analytics
SHARE THIS ARTICLE

In March 2011, the New York Times introduced a policy that would later be recognised as a milestone in media history. The newspaper, deemed one of the best in the world, declared that its online content would no longer be completely free — after the first 20 articles, readers would have to pay a small fee.

The move to introduce a paywall caused an uproar. The Times believed such a freemium model, offering a mix of free and paid content, was the way forward. The advent of the Internet drastically changed the nature of publishing and after the 2008 financial crisis, newspapers, including the Times, struggled to make money from advertising alone. They had to find a new profit-making avenue.

But naysayers proclaimed that readers, who they said had grown accustomed to conventional Internet wisdom that “information wants to be free”, would be reluctant to pay for something they read online. The Times quickly proved them wrong, amassing 324,000 digital subscribers just a year after the paywall was introduced. Today, that figure has grown to 5.7 million (despite the number of free articles offered dropping to five), with digital subscriptions raking in a revenue of US$146 million in the second quarter of 2020 alone. The Times’ success has helped to popularise paywalls — today, roughly seven in 10 newspapers operate some kind of paid subscription model.

“We now live in a digitised world where newspapers, music distributors, consulting companies, data broking firms, and so on sell information and data online,” says Assistant Professor Nan Chen at NUS Computing. “The issue is how do they sell this information and data?”

The answer is a complicated one, says Chen, who studies how consumers behave and the strategies firms take in digital markets. To convince buyers to part with their money, sellers have to first offer a free sample of their goods so that potential consumers can “verify the quality of the data and be convinced that they have valuable information,” he says.

The trick is finding the equilibrium point between free and paid content. “The seller has to make a tradeoff,” says Chen. Free information can help attract more customers, but offer too much and it will cut into your profits. Firms, therefore, continuously experiment with the optimal quantity of free versus paid content to offer.

Two things exacerbate this challenge further, says Chen. The first is competition between sellers and the second is consumers’ limited attention span in our information-saturated world. How do these factors influence selling strategy, he wondered.

A model

Chen delved into the problem at the start of last year, together with fellow NUS Computing professor Khim Yong Goh and then-PhD student Ding Li. Their aim was to use real-life data to create a mathematical model that would stimulate how consumers act in a competitive information market.

“We wanted to study how people like information buyers and newspaper readers behave,” explains Chen. “For example, how do they sample free information and decide which one to subscribe to.”

The researchers were also interested in examining how factors such as price and selling strategy influence a consumer’s decision to shell out money for content behind a paywall.

To build the model, the trio obtained data from iMaibo, a China-based online investment advisory platform (IAP) with more than four million users. iMaibo’s platform resembles that of Twitter, where numerous social media advisors — both amateur and certified ones — post real-time news, analysis, and investment advice related to the Chinese retail investor market. Consumers can view a limited number of ‘tweets’ from each advisor or seller (the exact number depends on the seller), before having to subscribe to the latter’s content on a daily, monthly, or quarterly basis.

Chen and his team gathered two years’ worth of data from iMaibo’s top 100 sellers — who together accounted for 81% of total content produced and 99.8% of paid tweets on the platform — to create their demand-supply model.

A nexus

The model led the researchers to some interesting findings. Most iMaibo consumers, they observed, usually visit only a small set of sellers each day. More than half would browse a single seller’s content, while 18% and 9% visit two and three sellers, respectively. And in the end, nine in 10 people subscribe to just one seller.

In addition, the number of tweets read daily by consumers tends to fall sharply — further proof of their limited attention. This short attention span could lead to a mismatch of what the consumer is seeking and the information he actually ends up with. However, information sellers may possibly benefit because “it may soften seller competition in the paid information market,” write Chen and his team in a paper published late last year.

“An information seller can tactically utilise free information to determine the intensity of competition he will face in the market of paid information,” they explain.

The team then turned to the factors that influenced a person’s decision to become a paid subscriber. They found that the more free tweets a seller offers, the more likely a consumer will visit his site. The more paid tweets a seller has, the more attractive his information appears, and the greater the number of paid subscribers he will have.

“From a platform owner’s point of view, the model helps to understand what the optimal price is and how to generate the highest revenue possible,” says Chen. “You can also think about whether free and paid information is good or bad, and how changing the equilibrium between the two affects the quality of information provided.”

“Should platforms restrict entry?” he asks. “Because the more sellers that enter the market, the more noise you have. But is more competition good or bad? That’s actually a very non-trivial question.”

“Ultimately, we want to add to the discussion on free versus paid information,” says Chen, “and how various pricing designs can affect consumer welfare.”

Paper:

Selling Information When Attention is Limited: An Empirical Analysis of an Online Investment Advisory Platform

Trending Posts

20200430-Brian-Lim-Research-Feature
30 April 2020
Human-centred explainable AI: Helping people to faithfully interpret machine learning with less mental effort
These days, artificial intelligence (AI) is everywhere we look. It’s what powers predictive searches on Google, enables Spotify and Amazon to recommend new songs and products, puts self-driving vehicles on ...
20190510_Wei_Kwok_Kee_Research_Feature
9 May 2019
Thinking Beyond STEM: A Lifelong Quest for Lifelong Learning
With science, technology, engineering and mathematics (STEM) skills in greater demand than ever before, many people see STEM education as a ticket to a successful and rewarding career. University graduates ...
ai-music-therapy-wangye
27 November 2024
Transforming Stroke Recovery with AI and Music Therapy

Harnessing the Power of Music AI to Heal Stroke Patients Many people, including Wang Ye, can attest to the healing power of music. On bad days, it helps us relieve ...

ATung-DiversiNews
14 February 2025
DiversiNews Helps Increase News Exposure and Broaden People’s Minds

Those of us who don’t belong to Gen Z or Alpha may recall simpler times, when there were no smartphones or internet, and the only news we got was via ...

20210913_SoC_Features_He_Bingsheng_ThunderGP_Final
24 September 2021
Making sense of messy data with ThunderGP
Choice is good, but sometimes having too much choice can be a bad thing. Just ask anyone who’s ever tried to delve into a new film on Netflix, discover new ...
20210215_SOC_Features_Damith_final
15 February 2021
More than Assignments: Developing Software for the Real World
In 2011, Damith Rajapakse was teaching a few modules at NUS Computing when he ran into a problem. Part of his modules comprised an aspect of project work, and he ...
20200528_Zhao-Shengdong-revised
1 June 2020
Vanquishing smartphone zombies with EYEditor
If you have been to parts of Orchard Road or Bugis Junction, two busy shopping streets in Singapore, you might have noticed something unusual. There, familiar “traffic light men” flash ...
20201005_Gait_Analysis_Feature_Article_Photo_Oct_5
5 October 2020
Watching People Walk
Life has a funny way of leading people down paths they least expect. Just ask NUS Computing lecturer Boyd Anderson. Two years ago, Anderson, then a PhD student, found himself ...
Kenji-STDE
30 December 2024
Unlocking the Power of High-Dimensional Simulations with STDE

In a world increasingly driven by artificial intelligence and complex computations, tackling the most challenging problems—from modeling galaxies to designing personalized medicine—requires innovation. One such breakthrough is the Stochastic Taylor ...

20200123_Yair_Zick_Research_Article_Photo-01
23 January 2020
Let’s maximise influence, but in a fair way
A few years ago, Yair Zick was attending a conference in Stockholm when he struck up a conversation with two researchers from the University of Southern California (USC). Zick, a ...
RF-OoiWeiTsang-LTS-Website
23 April 2025
Stream Without Limits: How LTS Technology Could Revolutionize Immersive 3D Experiences
LTS is a new system developed by NUS Computing researchers (Associate Professor Ooi Wei Tsang and PhD student Shi Yuang) in collaboration with researchers from the National Tsing Hua University ...
RF-OoiWeiTsang-SafeSpect-Website
4 June 2025
Seeing Safety: How Augmented Reality Could Transform Drone Inspections Forever
Associate Professor Ooi Wei Tsang and his team at NUS Computing have developed SafeSpect, an adaptive augmented reality system that enhances drone pilots' situational awareness for drone inspections. ...
20200904_Anand-Bhojan
4 September 2020
Bringing video games to life
Your heartbeat quickens as you watch your video game avatar run through the twisting corridors of the castle. There is still treasure to be found and a hostage to be ...
Features_TrevorECarlson2
15 June 2023
Plugging the Prefetcher Security Gap
Today’s world moves at such a breakneck speed that it has transformed us into a society that loathes to wait. Online deliveries turn up at our doorsteps in two hours ...
Future of Learning
22 October 2024
COACHing the Future: How Robots Are Revolutionising Learning

Unlocking the Future of Learning: Robots as Your Personal Coaches Imagine a world where robots don’t just assist with daily tasks but actively help you learn new skills. We’re talking ...

20190528_Bryan_Low_Research_Article-1
28 May 2019
What Bayesian Optimisation can teach us about baking better cookies and more
Mention “Bayesian Optimisation” to Professor Bryan Low Kian Hsiang and he begins to talk about baking cookies. That’s because to the uninitiated, concepts such as “distributed batch Gaussian process optimisation” ...
Fixing vulnerable computer programs with semantic reasoning
27 September 2023
Fixing Vulnerable Computer Programs with Semantic Reasoning
Debugging is the bane of many a computer programmer’s existence — a task that’s both immensely costly and time-consuming. For a start, locating the source of a software error, or ...
Newsbyte - Research Feature_Ambuj Varshney_AudioCast (1)
21 August 2025
Reimagining Connectivity: How AudioCast Delivers Ultra-Low-Power Wireless Communication at Scale
Enter AudioCast – a radically different approach to wireless communication for embedded devices. AudioCast introduces a new class of audio-broadcasting low-power tags that operate outside conventional radio spectrum – by ...
20200128_Vaibhav_Rajan_Research_Article_Photo-01
28 January 2020
Lost in masses of clinical data? Help is here
The intensive care unit where Dr. Jean-Daniel Chiche works in Paris is what you would expect from an ICU. Amidst an atmosphere of respectful quiet and hushed tones lie patients ...
20200713_Stanley-Kok
20 July 2020
Want to better categorise your products online? Try translation tech
Confined to their homes during the circuit breaker period, Singapore’s Covid-19 lockdown, people began ordering certain products in earnest: fitness equipment, home office accessories, flour and other baking goods. If, ...
Feature_Kuldeep_Meel
27 March 2023
New Algorithm Revolutionises a Decades-Old Estimation Problem
When Covid-19 came barrelling through the world, it upended nearly every aspect of our lives, forcing us to live, work, and play in completely new ways. We became accustomed to ...
20201222_Zhao_Shengdong_feature_Final
21 December 2020
LiveSnippets: Writing on-the-go
In April 2018, Hyeongcheol Kim flew to Montreal for work. The young PhD student was excited — it was his first time in the Canadian city and the conference he ...
RF-MohanKankanhalli-BullyingAI-Website
4 June 2025
Bullying the Machine: What AI’s Reactions to Psychological Pressure Teach Us About Vulnerability
A new study led by Professor Mohan Kankanhalli (Provost’s Chair Professor and Director of NUS AI Institute) reveals that large language models exhibit human-like psychological vulnerabilities when subjected to AI-driven ...
RF-ZhangJiaheng-zkSNARKs-Website
4 March 2025
Breaking the Bottleneck: Making Zero-Knowledge Proofs Practical at Scale
A team led by Asst Prof Zhang Jiaheng has developed a scalable, privacy-preserving way to generate zk-SNARKs—unlocking faster, secure proof generation across multiple machines. ...
ResearchFeature-Wang Bohan-Web
1 March 2025
Revolutionising 3D Modelling with Tetsphere Splatting: A New Era of Digital Geometry
Explore how a groundbreaking technique developed by NUS Computing’s Assistant Professor Wang Bohan is set to transform digital geometry. Tetsphere Splatting, recently presented at ICLR 2025, uses virtual clay-like spheres ...
Lim_Shi_Ying
4 January 2023
Problem-first or product-first?
As any Ph.D. student will tell you, paychecks at that level aren’t especially generous. “I was always trying to find cheaper alternatives for household items,” recalls Lim Shi Ying of ...
20181011_Jack_Jiang_Research_Article
11 October 2018
Online Shopping and the Science of Serendipity: NUS Computing Researcher Jack Jiang on Product Search in Social Commerce
Have you ever gone to an e-commerce website with the intention of buying one specific thing, but then ended up with something totally different? ...
20210318_Features_Ravi_Suppiah
19 March 2021
Teaching Hands-On Computer Engineering
For Ravi Suppiah, the term “teaching innovation” has never just been some far-off ideal to strive for when one has the time or energy for reflective improvement. Instead, it’s ingrained ...
20211015_SoC_Features_Abhik_R_Bug_Bane_Final
22 October 2021
Bug-bane begone — enter the era of Automated Program Repair
Consider a programmer sitting at her desk, trying to fix an error in a software system. First, she had to determine what was causing the problem and trace its source ...
20210902_SoC_Features_Heng_Cheng_Suang_FinTech
3 September 2021
Empowering people through Fintech
In 2014, Tan Tianhui was in the second year of her PhD at NUS Computing when she heard about a “special product” that everyone back home in China couldn’t stop ...
Facebook Instagram Telegram Linkedin Youtube
Support NUS Computing
  • Computing 1
    13 Computing Drive
    Singapore 117417
  • +65 6516 2727
  • Contact Us
  • Locate Us
  • Find Our Venues
Additional Links
NUS COMPUTING
  • About Us
  • Programmes
  • News
  • Events
  • Innovation & Entrepreneurship
  • Recruiters
  • About Us
  • Programmes
  • News
  • Events
  • Innovation & Entrepreneurship
  • Recruiters
Programmes
  • Undergraduate
  • Master’s
  • Doctoral
  • Graduate Certificates
  • Executive Education
  • Undergraduate
  • Master’s
  • Doctoral
  • Graduate Certificates
  • Executive Education
ADMISSIONS
  • Undergraduate
  • Graduate
  • Financial Support
  • Undergraduate
  • Graduate
  • Financial Support
RESEARCH
  • Research Centres
  • Research Areas
  • Research Centres
  • Research Areas
DEPARTMENTS
  • Department of Computer Science
  • Department of Information Systems and Analytics
  • Department of Computer Science
  • Department of Information Systems and Analytics
RESOURCES
  • School Directory
  • Student Portal
  • Facilities & Services
  • NUS WebMail
  • NUS Canvas
  • Student Jobs
  • School Directory
  • Student Portal
  • Facilities & Services
  • NUS WebMail
  • NUS Canvas
  • Student Jobs
NUS COMPUTING
  • About Us
  • Programmes
  • News
  • Events
  • Innovation & Entrepreneurship
  • Recruiters
  • About Us
  • Programmes
  • News
  • Events
  • Innovation & Entrepreneurship
  • Recruiters
Programmes
  • Undergraduate
  • Master’s
  • Doctoral
  • Graduate Certificates
  • Executive Education
  • Undergraduate
  • Master’s
  • Doctoral
  • Graduate Certificates
  • Executive Education
ADMISSIONS
  • Undergraduate
  • Graduate
  • Financial Support
  • Undergraduate
  • Graduate
  • Financial Support
RESEARCH
  • Research Centres
  • Research Areas
  • Research Centres
  • Research Areas
DEPARTMENTS
  • Department of Computer Science
  • Department of Information Systems and Analytics
  • Department of Computer Science
  • Department of Information Systems and Analytics
RESOURCES
  • School Directory
  • Student Portal
  • Facilities & Services
  • NUS WebMail
  • NUS Canvas
  • Student Jobs
  • School Directory
  • Student Portal
  • Facilities & Services
  • NUS WebMail
  • NUS Canvas
  • Student Jobs

© National University of Singapore. All Rights Reserved. • Legal • Branding guidelines